Last month, there was an extraordinary exchange when Ofcom’s newly appointed chair, Sir Ian Cheshire, appeared in front of the House of Commons Culture, Media and Sport select committee. He was accompanied by Ofcom’s Chief Executive, Dame Melanie Dawes, and at one point was challenged by MP Rupa Huq on whether Ofcom was being too lenient in regulating GB News for impartiality: “I think the public feel you are not applying the rules enough… and so are letting them get away with it”. She mentioned those “not of the left” who had been highly critical of Ofcom’s inaction, including former ITN and Ofcom executive Stewart Purvis.

Sir Ian’s response was remarkable: “I encourage Stewart and Alan [Rusbridger] to set up a left-wing version of GB News.” This prompted a stinging response from Purvis, now published on the committee website, for questioning his long-standing political impartiality; and a delightfully satirical response from Rusbridger proposing a slate of new programmes on his putative new channel GB Woke (published in Prospect).

Those responses aside, Cheshire’s unfortunate reply was extraordinary for two reasons. First, it appears to be an explicit admission that GB News is a right-wing channel, despite multiple protestations to the contrary. Much more worryingly, it suggests that Cheshire either does not understand or is ignorant of the law governing impartiality on Ofcom-licensed channels.

That law is enshrined in the Communications Act 2003, which gives Ofcom a statutory duty to ensure that “news included in television and radio services is presented with due impartiality”. Section 320 of the Act spells out precisely what that statutory duty entails: special impartiality requirements apply to all programmes dealing with “matters of political or industrial controversy” and “matters relating to current public policy”.

Over the years, there has been flexibility for news stations or channels that clearly demonstrate even-handedness over their schedule, such as LBC. But GB News barely nods in the direction of a bi-partisan approach. Sometimes a left-of-centre figure is set up as the proverbial punchball for an attack on, say, climate change or asylum policy. But, as the roster of high-profile presenters from Farage to Rees-Mogg demonstrates, the channel, in my view, is essentially wall-to-wall catnip for the anti-woke culture warriors of the right.

News or current affairs? Ofcom’s false distinction

I believe that this partisan content is clearly contrary to the 2003 Communications Act. So why does Ofcom fail to act? In its response to critics, its self-justification falls essentially under two headings: an artificial distinction between news and current affairs and the need to safeguard freedom of expression.

Following a consultation on whether rules around politicians presenting news programmes should be tightened, Ofcom was expected to introduce a stricter regime. In fact, nothing really happened. Ofcom still has no problem in allowing politicians to present “current affairs” programmes which it distinguishes from “news” programmes.

This is an entirely contrived distinction, invented by the regulator, which does not exist in law. Its absurdity was laid bare by a week’s content analysis of GB News evening programmes carried out by Stewart Purvis and Chris Banatvala, Ofcom’s founding director of standards, whose results are described in their submission to Ofcom’s consultation. In total, they found that 42 different subjects were covered during those programmes, of which 39 were news events of the day.

In other words, the content on GB News during its peak viewing hours is overwhelmingly – to use the words contained in statute – “matters of political or industrial controversy” and “matters relating to current public policy”.

Just how much this practice differs from the rest of Europe was illustrated last month in a Demos report which provided evidence from 37 media regulators. The only two countries which identified examples of serving politicians presenting news or current affairs programmes, apart from the UK, were Iceland and Malta.

Freedom of expression – another phoney argument

Then there is the freedom of expression defence. This has been repeatedly used by Dame Melanie Dawes in public interviews and select committee hearings, and we heard the same mantra from Sir Ian Cheshire at the select committee hearing: “we also have a duty on free speech and freedom of expression, so there is a balancing act”.

This is a disingenuous argument that presupposes a conflict between free speech and impartiality. In fact, it is perfectly feasible for Ofcom to safeguard free expression while also implementing its statutory obligations on impartiality. It has long been established through case law in the European Court of Human Rights that interference with the right to freedom of expression may be justifiable if it is “necessary in a democratic society”.

That approach was reinforced in a 2020 High Court judgment, ironically involving a challenge by Russian news channel RT to an Ofcom sanctions decision. In rejecting RT’s appeal, the court determined that impartiality was an essential ingredient of an informed democracy: “permitting a provider of television services to avoid the requirement of ‘due impartiality’, even for one programme, would severely harm the quality of political discourse in this country”.

Time for action

Ofcom’s approach to impartiality is finally receiving the attention it deserves in Parliament and in government. Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy told the DCMS committee last year that “it is an area in which we intend to act”. She expressed concern to the Society of Editors in March this year about a “dangerous blurring” of fact and polemic in broadcasting and said she was “exploring action in this space”.

In a Westminster Hall debate two weeks ago, MPs took it in turns to criticise Ofcom’s performance across the board, but particularly its inaction on broadcasting standards. Asked what action the government intends to take, the minister responding, Stephanie Peacock, repeated the government line: “We are currently considering a range of options to tackle this issue and will set out more information and a decision in due course”.

It is now time to act. Broadcast news still commands enormous trust in the UK, a reputation built on decades of institutional and regulatory commitment to impartial, accurate reporting. Overtly partisan channels risk undermining that tradition and need a robust regulatory response, as Parliament intended.

My view is that Ofcom is clearly failing to do the job entrusted to it by Parliament, inventing distinctions that do not exist in law to justify its inertia. A small amendment to the Communications Act could easily remove any ambiguity and oblige Ofcom to do its job. Lisa Nandy should bring it forward now.

Steven Barnett is Professor of Communications at the University of Westminster and an established writer and broadcaster, who has been involved in communications policy analysis for 35 years. He has given evidence or served as an adviser to several parliamentary committees, and was appointed this year as specialist adviser to the Commons Culture, Media and Sport select committee for its inquiry into BBC Charter Renewal, published on 1 October 2026.

This post originally appeared on the Media Society Substack and is reproduced with the permission of the author,