The International Forum for Responsible Media Blog

Tag: Justification

Case Law: Starr v Ward, Justification defence succeeds in Freddie Starr’s “groping” libel claim

Starr WardThe libel claim brought by entertainer Freddie Starr against Karin Ward has been dismissed by Mr Justice Nicol following an eight day trial.  In a judgment handed down on 10 July 2015 ([2015] EWHC 1987 (QB)) the judge held that the allegations made by Ms Ward concerning Mr Starr’s conduct at a recording of a Jimmy Savile TV programme in 1974 were true. Continue reading

Case Law: Cruddas v Calvert, Sunday Times appeal allowed in part, ex Conservative Treasurer’s damages reduced to £50,000

Sunday Times CruddasThe Sunday Times and two of its journalists have been partially successful in their appeal against the decision of Tugendhat J in Cruddas v Calvert awarding damages of  £180,000 to former Conservative party treasurer, Peter Cruddas ([2015] EWCA Civ 171). The Court of Appeal unanimously allowed the appeal on one of three grounds, finding that the allegation of corrupt conduct was true. Continue reading

Case Law: Rothschild v Associated Newspapers Limited, Court of Appeal upholds justification defence – Valerie Paisner

pictureIn last month’s unanimous judgment in Rothschild v Associated Newspapers Limited ([2013] EWCA Civ 197) the Court of Appeal upheld a decision that the defence of justification had been established in a claim brought by the financier Nat Rothschild against the Daily Mail. The case provides interesting guidance on the circumstances in which a defendant need prove only part of the defamatory allegations which have been made. Continue reading

© 2023 Inforrm's Blog

Theme by Anders NorénUp ↑